Reddit User Sparks Online Debate By Refusing To Care For Neighbor's Dog While She Was In The Emergency Room

Leona Martinez
Dec 19, 2023
Dec 19, 2023

The Redditor is an introvert. They recently had a problem with their neighbor. The neighbor, who previously stayed silent, suddenly interrupted the OP's work-from-home routine with a surprising request for help.

As shared in a post on the r/AmItheA**hole subreddit, when the OP was in a Zoom meeting for work, they received a call from the neighbor and were asked to go into her apartment to let her dog out. The OP found discomfort with this request, so they refused. The neighbor got upset and acted rudely, leaving the OP wrestling with conflicting emotions.

Was the OP in the wrong? Scroll down to read the entire story and share your opinions with us in the comments!

Source: bionic.co.uk (not the actual photo)

Here's the full story:

Source: Consistent-Staff4349

Neighbor called OP during work hours and asked them to let her dog out

Source: Consistent-Staff4349

OP declined their neighbor's request, so the neighbor reacted rudely

Source: Consistent-Staff4349

The neighbor should have reached out to someone with an established relationship first

Source: swillshop

OP is in the wrong for refusing to help in what seems like an emergency situation

Source: FrobisherLetters

Neighbors should mutually assist each other with favors

Source: Lesley82

The situation would be different with a close friend

Source: rangerman2002

OP has the right to refuse

Source: thejokergotaway

OP is not obligated to fulfill favors

Source: 1nsert-username-here

The OP is not obligated to help neighbors

Source: Mission-Factor-4806

The OP should help the neighbor in this case and in the future

Source: MsBaseball34

People who claim to be introverts are simply unfriendly

Source: kcamms97

OP is not wrong because there will be potential risks involved in helping

Source: fleshybit

The neighbor should call her friends or family for help

Source: delovelylilah

The neighbor should have seeked assistance from someone else

The neighbor should seek assistance from someone else

Source: Smitty_80013

This Redditor would help the dog if they were the OP

Source: pupperoni42

The neighbor could have called a family member for assistance

Source: The_Fires_Of_Orc

The OP may not receive help in their own emergency situation in the future

Source: FluffyPal

What are your thoughts on the situation? Do you believe the OP was justified in refusing to help the neighbor, or do you think being a good neighbor should take precedence?

Have you ever faced a similar dilemma with neighbors, and how did you handle it? Share your opinions and experiences – we'd love to hear your perspective!

Reddit User Sparks Online Debate By Refusing To Care For Neighbor's Dog While She Was In The Emergency Room

Here's the full story:

OP's neighbor recently texted them, sharing neighborhood gossip

Neighbor called OP during work hours and asked them to let her dog out

OP declined their neighbor's request, so the neighbor reacted rudely

The neighbor should have reached out to someone with an established relationship first

OP is in the wrong for refusing to help in what seems like an emergency situation

Neighbors should mutually assist each other with favors

The situation would be different with a close friend

OP has the right to refuse

OP is not obligated to fulfill favors

The OP is not obligated to help neighbors

The OP should help the neighbor in this case and in the future

People who claim to be introverts are simply unfriendly

OP is not wrong because there will be potential risks involved in helping

The neighbor should call her friends or family for help

The neighbor should have seeked assistance from someone else

This Redditor would help the dog if they were the OP

The neighbor could have called a family member for assistance

The OP may not receive help in their own emergency situation in the future

Related Articles