14 Craziest Reasons Actors Were Rejected For Movie Roles

Hollywood is a chaotic industry where careers may be created or destroyed in a short time. An actor's fame can quickly rise if they are cast in the right role, and from that point on, more attractive offers are sure to come across their table.
Often, it takes years and years to "break into" the moviemaking industry, with hundreds of auditions heartbreakingly resulting in varying "no's," "you're not quite right for the parts," or "it was lovely meeting you". It's not a surprise to discover that some of Hollywood's brightest actors have all experienced being rejected for a role they'd love to play.
Many of the most famous, beloved, and acclaimed performers are very familiar with rejection, having been turned down for a role for one of the many reasons that a filmmaker may decide to go in another direction. Surprisingly, not all of the reasons are appropriate; several of them are pretty ridiculous!
Here are 14 actors who were rejected from TV roles because of their looks, age, race, or other unfair reasons. Scroll down to read more!

#1 Chris Pine was rejected for Ryan Atwood in "The O.C." because of his acne

Source: Daniel Knighton / Getty Images for Paramount Pictures

Casting director Patrick Rush told that his heart was broken at the time he met Chris Pine. His skin was bad. He remembered that Chris was so good.

Source: Frazer Harrison / Getty Images

The role went to Ben McKenzie.

Source: Fox / Via

#2 Sheryl Lee Ralph earned a role in a pilot in the 1980s, but a producer fired her and informed her she wasn't "Black enough"

Source: Michael Ochs Archives / Getty Images

She told People, "Those were his words. It was horrible. I can still remember the way I felt."

Source: Paras Griffin / Getty Images for CMPR Inc.

#3 Before Sarah Jessica Parker finally decided to take the role, Lisa Edelstein had a contract to play Carrie Bradshaw in "Sex and the City"

Source: Steve Granitz / FilmMagic / Via Getty

Lisa told, "I was either going to do it or not. It all depended on whether she said yes."

Source: Kevin Mazur / Getty Images for WarnerMedia

Lisa was fired from the show after Sarah opted to take the role, and she later said that the play "was too painful."

Source: Kristin Callahan/Everett Collection

#4 Regé-Jean Page was supposedly not cast as Seyg-El (Superman's grandfather) on Krypton due to his race

Source: Mike Marsland / Mike Marsland / WireImage / Via Getty

 It is said that the production boss said Superman couldn't have a Black grandfather. He rejected the reports, though.

Source: Ian Walton / Getty Images

In response to the reports, Regé-Jean tweeted, "Hearing about these conversations hurts no less now than it did back then. The clarifications almost hurt more tbh."

Source: Mike Marsland / Mike Marsland / WireImage / Via Getty

 The role went to Cameron Cuffe.

Source: Steffan Hill / ©Syfy / courtesy Everett Collection

#5 Daniel Kaluuya was rejected from the role to his competitor's advantage

Source: NBC / NBC / NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images

Daniel Kaluuya once went through ten rounds of auditions for a program in English about aliens. He nearly got the lead role but it went to another actor. Daniel Kaluuya realized his competitor had been given an advantage. He said "the other guy had been given an acting coach. They didn't love me as they loved him."

Source: Prince Williams / Getty Images

#6 Alden Ehrenreich was rejected for the role of Dan Humphrey in "Gossip Girl" because he wasn't "tall enough" to play Blake Lively's love interest

Source: Frazer Harrison / Getty Images for Paramount Pictures

Alden is 5'9", and Blake is 5'10".

Source: Jun Sato / WireImage via Getty / GWR/Star Max/GC Images / Via Getty

The role went to Penn Badgley, who's 5'9".

Source: Giovanni Rufino / © The CW / Courtesy Everett Collection

#7 Marshall Herskovitz missed out on the role of Angela Chase in "My So-Called Life" because of her beauty

Source: NBC / NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images

Marshall said that Alicia was so beautiful that would make people would just tell about her looks. Her outstanding appearance was not suitable for a normal girl.

Source: Ron Galella, Ltd. / Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

The part instead went to Claire Danes.

Source: Jeffery Newbury / TV Guide /© ABC / Courtesy Everett Collection

#8 In the "Stumptown" pilot, Mark Webber was replaced due to his appearance

Source: Gilbert Carrasquillo / Getty Images

He tweeted, "Look, I’m a straight white male so I know my journey has been way less painful in this warped industry, but I’m being recast in a network television show because I’m not handsome enough for the executives."

Source: Gilbert Carrasquillo / Getty Images

He thought that these treatments were so degrading and he believed that network television was dying because of these "executive" decisions.

Source: Albert L. Ortega / Getty Images

 The role went to Jake Johnson.

Source: ABC / Via

#9 Mindy Kaling was rejected because the producers determined she wasn't "beautiful or funny enough" to play the part

Source: Steve Granitz / FilmMagic / Via Getty

She told the Guardian that she felt like karmically, she was vindicated, but at the time it felt terrible.

Source: Mark Sagliocco / WireImage / Via Getty

#10 Mädchen Amick didn't get the role because she didn't look old enough

Source: Walter Mcbride / Corbis via Getty Images

In the "Gilmore Girls" audition process, the network determined Mädchen Amick "didn't seem old enough to be a mother".

She told TVLine, "The network said I didn’t seem old enough to be a mother, which I had thought was kind of the whole point."

Source: Rodin Eckenroth / FilmMagic / Via Getty

The role went to Lauren Graham.

Source: Marsha Blackburn / ©The CW /Courtesy Everett Collection

However, series creator Amy Sherman-Palladino allowed Mädchen to go to Stars Hollow by having her return in three episodes as Sherry Tinsdale.


#11 On "Girl Meets World", Elliot Matthews was originally portrayed by Teo Halm. But, his character was dropped after the pilot

Source: Rodin Eckenroth / Getty Images

He noticed on Twitter that he wouldn’t be on "Girl Meets World"

Source: James Lemke Jr / WireImage / Via Getty

Danielle Fishel, who plays Topanga, responded, "Teo, you are an incredible talent and I adore you. You may still call me 'mom.'"

Source: Ron Tom/©Disney Channel/courtesy Everett Collection

#12 Alyson Hannigan's daughters Satyana and Keeva Denisof were slated to play Lily Aldrin's second child on "How I Met Your Mother," but the producers decided they were "too old"

Source: Michael Bezjian / Via Getty

Alyson told HuffPost, "I was like, 'You fired my child. First of all, that’s ageism. I don’t think you’re allowed to fire her because she’s too old.'"

Source: Vivien Killilea / WireImage / Via Getty

The role of Daisy Eriksen was played by an uncredited baby.

Source: Cliff Lipson/©CBS / courtesy Everett Collection

#13 In the "Man with a Plan" pilot, Jenna Fischer's episode was only ever aired during the 2016 CBS Upfronts. Before the preview, the network chose to recast her

Source: Axelle / FilmMagic / Via Getty

Her lack of chemistry with co-star Matt LeBlanc, according to reports, was the deciding factor. "It was fine, but we think we can do better in terms of the chemistry between the two of them," CBS's then-Entertainment President Glenn Geller told the Wrap.

Source: Leonard Adam / WireImage / Via Getty

The part went to Liza Snyder

Source: Darren Michaels / ©CBS / Courtesy Everett Collection

#14 For taking a piece of candy from Lorne Michaels' desk, Marc Maron believed he lost his chance to join the Saturday Night Live cast

Source: Lester Cohen / Getty Images for The Bob Dylan Center

He told the New York Times, "I think I was a little high on pot. Some pictures were facing [Mr. Michaels], and in front of the pictures was a bowl of candy. It was all very loaded."

Source: NBC / NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images

"Then he just starts looking at me, to a point where Steve Higgins [then an SNL producer] goes, 'Lorne?' And Lorne goes, 'You can tell a lot by looking into someone’s eyes.' And then I took a candy," he continued. He said, "Lorne looked at Steve, and the meeting was over. I thought I failed the candy test."

Source: Helen King / Getty Images

Source: Tommaso Boddi / FilmMagic / Via Getty

But Lorne later clarified on Marc's WTF podcast that his denial had nothing to do with the sweets; SNL just didn't have a space for him.

Source: NBC / NBCU Photo Bank / NBCUniversal via Getty Images

Share this article