7 Details From Harry Potter Books That Were Poorly Ruined In The Movies
A Harry Potter TV series remake is being discussed by Warner Bros., and it would provide an opportunity to fix some of the most significant flaws in the first films. The Movies.are recognizable and well-loved, although a few elements from the Harry Potter books were changed or eliminated to fit the shorter format or to add drama to the screen. As a result, the tone of Harry's narrative varied slightly from one to the next, however, some of those details were illogical or even awful.
Yet if a TV show ever happened, it might be able to address some of the biggest problems. Of course, there are a ton of ways the WB and HBO may do this wrong—fans will probably stay doubtful until they dispel that notion. The eight Harry Potter movies still have a lot of room for improvement, particularly in regard to some of its most criticized flaws.
One of the endearing aspects of the wizarding realm is how little-experienced witches and wizards have no idea how to dress correctly in the Muggle world. Everyone in the magical community wore robes in the Harry Potter books rather than more contemporary clothing, however, this was changed for the movies. Although Harry and his companions were frequently seen in jeans and sweaters, the three-piece suits in Harry Potter and the Fantastic Beasts have long troubled fans. The TV show should provide a more authentic picture of the wizarding realm.
Dobby the house elf was one of the Harry Potter series' purest characters, making the tragedy of his passing in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows all the more tragic. This was much lessened in the films, though, since Dobby was only seen in Chamber of Secrets before being killed in Deathly Hallows, as opposed to almost every film as he was in the novels. This seemed like a tremendous injustice to his supporters. His parts were probably deleted from the films to save money and time on animating him, but an HBO series might be able to pull it off.
Hogwarts is one of the most fantastical features in the Harry Potter books. Fans have always wished to visit the castle in person since it is essentially a tangible embodiment of magic. Of course, the gorgeous set of the movies helped, but they lost something special that the novels frequently emphasized—the everyday casual experience. On the page, the Golden Trio put off finishing their schoolwork in the Gryffindor common room, fighting with snowballs in the courtyard, and making jokes with Fred and George in the Great Hall. All of it contributed to the magic of Hogwarts even if none of it was necessary to the story.
Although the magic laws in the Harry Potter books were frequently flexible, they generally followed some form of logic. Unfortunately, the Harry Potter films ignored this in favor of visual effects, which made die-hard fans furious. Nearly every wizarding conflict in Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts involved the employment of phenomena like Priori Incantatum, which could only occur during a fight thanks to the wands of Harry and Voldemort's brother. In addition, the spell Apparition, which causes a wizard to vanish and reappear someplace else, was changed to include flying through a cloud of smoke. It didn't make sense at all.
Making room for all the characters is one of the biggest challenges that book-to-film adaptations frequently encounter. Harry encountered several characters in the Harry Potter universe, all of varying significance to his narrative. Obviously, some of them might be easily removed. Nonetheless, others like Charlie Weasley, Peeves, and Winky the house elf stood out because of their absence. Some who had cherished these people's positions in the novels found this to be disheartening. To everyone's delight, a remake may bring back these missing Harry Potter characters.
The culmination of the Harry Potter series was the hunt for the Horcrux. A lot of background material was provided in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, and it continued in Deathly Hallows when Harry assumed the role after Dumbledore's passing. Voldemort's Horcruxes remained a mystery even in the novels. Even after his studies with Dumbledore, Harry lacked a lot of background knowledge. Yet, Harry was far more knowledgeable than in the movies regarding the items and the prospective places. Harry probably found them because of luck, not wisdom.
Professor Trelawney's prophecy, which explained how a boy born at the end of July would be Lord Voldemort's downfall, was mostly ignored in the Harry Potter films. This meant that the possibility that Neville and Harry may have been affected by this was likewise only discussed in the novels. This was upsetting since the insecure boy's character journey was one of the most dramatic in the entire series. Even though Neville didn't become the Boy Who Lived, the Harry Potter series makes a big deal out of how chance played a big part in everything. The Harry Potter movies missed out on a fantastic plot by leaving out this information.
Yet if a TV show ever happened, it might be able to address some of the biggest problems. Of course, there are a ton of ways the WB and HBO may do this wrong—fans will probably stay doubtful until they dispel that notion. The eight Harry Potter movies still have a lot of room for improvement, particularly in regard to some of its most criticized flaws.
Muggle outfits are everywhere in the Harry Potter films
One of the endearing aspects of the wizarding realm is how little-experienced witches and wizards have no idea how to dress correctly in the Muggle world. Everyone in the magical community wore robes in the Harry Potter books rather than more contemporary clothing, however, this was changed for the movies. Although Harry and his companions were frequently seen in jeans and sweaters, the three-piece suits in Harry Potter and the Fantastic Beasts have long troubled fans. The TV show should provide a more authentic picture of the wizarding realm.
Dobby ought to have appeared in more Harry Potter films
Dobby the house elf was one of the Harry Potter series' purest characters, making the tragedy of his passing in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows all the more tragic. This was much lessened in the films, though, since Dobby was only seen in Chamber of Secrets before being killed in Deathly Hallows, as opposed to almost every film as he was in the novels. This seemed like a tremendous injustice to his supporters. His parts were probably deleted from the films to save money and time on animating him, but an HBO series might be able to pull it off.
Student life scenes in Hogwarts were very minimal
Hogwarts is one of the most fantastical features in the Harry Potter books. Fans have always wished to visit the castle in person since it is essentially a tangible embodiment of magic. Of course, the gorgeous set of the movies helped, but they lost something special that the novels frequently emphasized—the everyday casual experience. On the page, the Golden Trio put off finishing their schoolwork in the Gryffindor common room, fighting with snowballs in the courtyard, and making jokes with Fred and George in the Great Hall. All of it contributed to the magic of Hogwarts even if none of it was necessary to the story.
Dueling and apparition is ruined
Although the magic laws in the Harry Potter books were frequently flexible, they generally followed some form of logic. Unfortunately, the Harry Potter films ignored this in favor of visual effects, which made die-hard fans furious. Nearly every wizarding conflict in Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts involved the employment of phenomena like Priori Incantatum, which could only occur during a fight thanks to the wands of Harry and Voldemort's brother. In addition, the spell Apparition, which causes a wizard to vanish and reappear someplace else, was changed to include flying through a cloud of smoke. It didn't make sense at all.
Too many important characters were left out
Making room for all the characters is one of the biggest challenges that book-to-film adaptations frequently encounter. Harry encountered several characters in the Harry Potter universe, all of varying significance to his narrative. Obviously, some of them might be easily removed. Nonetheless, others like Charlie Weasley, Peeves, and Winky the house elf stood out because of their absence. Some who had cherished these people's positions in the novels found this to be disheartening. To everyone's delight, a remake may bring back these missing Harry Potter characters.
The Horcruxs were found too easily in the movies
The culmination of the Harry Potter series was the hunt for the Horcrux. A lot of background material was provided in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, and it continued in Deathly Hallows when Harry assumed the role after Dumbledore's passing. Voldemort's Horcruxes remained a mystery even in the novels. Even after his studies with Dumbledore, Harry lacked a lot of background knowledge. Yet, Harry was far more knowledgeable than in the movies regarding the items and the prospective places. Harry probably found them because of luck, not wisdom.
Neville Longbottom’s story has not been done properly
Professor Trelawney's prophecy, which explained how a boy born at the end of July would be Lord Voldemort's downfall, was mostly ignored in the Harry Potter films. This meant that the possibility that Neville and Harry may have been affected by this was likewise only discussed in the novels. This was upsetting since the insecure boy's character journey was one of the most dramatic in the entire series. Even though Neville didn't become the Boy Who Lived, the Harry Potter series makes a big deal out of how chance played a big part in everything. The Harry Potter movies missed out on a fantastic plot by leaving out this information.
Share this article
Advertisement